Liam Sercombe

[iscalad]

Re: liam sercombe

alright then,

I will pose you a question considering you have all the answers,

is Sercombe better than Carlisle ? if so why ?

Liam plays for a L1 side. Wayne can't get into a L2 side. As ******** would say. Simples

 

[older-codger]

Re: liam sercombe

They are different types of player so that kind of comparison is futile. You may as well compare, say Moxey or Kellow

 

[Mr Jan Yeo]

Re: liam sercombe

alright then,

I will pose you a question considering you have all the answers,

is Sercombe better than Carlisle ? if so why ?

Carlisle lacks drive, he doubted his own ability so much that he chose to go down the A380 to play BSP football rather than stay put and play L2 football.

 

[Wellyred]

Re: liam sercombe

Funny though, he managed to turn in a decent effort against Leeds.

It's turning into inconsistency/when he's in the mood.

agree. but if im going to be ultra picky he's the kind of player that plays a good game on a good pitch. today was a sh*te pitch..i know its the same for both players but they had no playmaker either.

 

[wemissmoxey]

Re: liam sercombe

if my memory serves me correctly he chose a 2 year deal at torquay rather the 1 year deal at city,

can one argue with that ?

 

[angelic upstart]

Re: liam sercombe

alright then,

I will pose you a question considering you have all the answers,

is Sercombe better than Carlisle ? if so why ?

You're the one giving answers. I'm the one asking the questions and countering your argument.

I can't actually answer the question, Carlisle is a right winger. Sercombe is a centre midfielder. I would say Sercombe has more potential, is more adaptable, has a better shot and defends better. Wayne has a better cross though.

 

[Mr Jan Yeo]

Re: liam sercombe

if my memory serves me correctly he chose a 2 year deal at torquay rather the 1 year deal at city,

can one argue with that ?

Yeah, me and many other Grecians. I would prefer a footballer to have enough belief that he would expect to perform well enough to extend the 1 year deal. Instead he showed Exeter his heels and is now ocassionally plying his trade with Torquay.

 

[oldbutwise]

Re: liam sercombe

He's only 19 give the lad a break he was quality last week!

 

[wemissmoxey]

Re: liam sercombe

maybe he has a family to think of and the 2 year deal was the only option

 

[Mr Jan Yeo]

Re: liam sercombe

maybe he has a family to think of and the 2 year deal was the only option

His choice, merely saying that it's something which I don't agree with and, IMO, displays a lack of desire.